Journal of Other Forum Analysis

[Not an Alt Account]

Found rustynails alt:

Some dude talks about you can't practice judaism in SA:

You're telling me a country where Jews are legally prohibited from "practicing Judaism" in public isn't a great place for queer people?

Enters totally not rustynails' alt to defend allah:

That's a rule for everything unislamic, it's not targeted spefically at Judaism . Every Islamic Arab country has the same rules, do whatever you want in your home, but don't do it in public.
Anyways, your comment isn't relevant to the op.

and he keeps going:

Well it's better than making it out to be anti semitic, which it isn't. Also, if you actually look into the enforcement of these policies, they aren't enforced, there's like 200+ unofficial churches which were working towards being official recognised. Not sure about Judaism, but again there's not any specific policies against it. If you didn't know Christians and Jews are considered better than other religions to Muslims as they are people of the book, so I assume they'd be treated similarly.

Edit - https://www.i24news.tv/en/news/inte...uilding-bridges-as-family-with-mutual-history

Seems it's not even a thing, like many laws it's just there but not enforced.

Because it's not targeting any specific religion, as I said, pointing out it's anti semitic specifically implies they are targeting Jews specifically, which the original comment was explicitly saying, which they SA aren't . You can be a practicing jew in SA, Jews can enter a mosque and pray however they like for example, it's a part of Islam which Saudi cannot deny . Jews can pray in public as long as it doesn't affect anyone else (this would also apply to Muslims FYI). The laws are there to prevent preaching etc. Which also affects strands of Islam or those of opposing politics.
I'm defending them because it's not accurate and is largely fueled by western propaganda by people who have never visited the country . I'm not a fan of Saudi's leadership as a Muslim either, but posts like the ones I replied to aren't accurate.

Yes and that's why I said I don't like their leadership. However, making false/misleading claims about it isn't the way to bring attention to it.
The original post was implying it being specifically targeted at being anti Jewish, as I explained that was my problem, I've explained this already.

That is kind of the case, as long as its in private, but you can't promote lgbtq ideals in public which isn't an issue for most lgbtq people, but it is stifling freedom of speech etc. Public displays of affection aren't allowed for straight people, so it's the same for lgbtq. However, the Muslim countries which share the same laws as SA, also use it to persecute people that criticise them (although I don't follow it closely) so lgbt rights protrsters get arrested for example, so freedom of speech is not a thing. Oppressing free speech is also against the teachings of Islam & Muhammad so that's why there's increasing discontent in the Muslim world with SA.

Starts here if you want to read it all:
https://www.resetera.com/threads/march-11-2024-aftermath-saudi-arabia%E2%80%99s-state-sponsored-gaming-booth-is-upsetting-queer-pax-east-attendees.827028/?post=121612299#post-121612299

Daily absolutely haram Sweeney:

Spoiler:  (click to show)(click to hide)