Journal of Other Forum Analysis

[Besticus Maximus]

https://www.resetera.com/threads/j-k-rowling-and-her-legacy-of-hate-the-uk-gender-critical-movement.643740/post-128116770

I know she's oblivious, but I don't know how she can't see that highlighting a trans athlete who didn't even qualify for the finals hurts her argument that they have an unfair advantage.

They always trot out this defense even though when you look trans women they are this tiny percentage (0.15%) but somehow managed to win in disproportionately large numbers. 

https://womenssportspolicy.org/253-male-victories-in-female-sports/

This dude is like twice the age of these other competitors and he's still competitive. But no, these trans women are so weak. Then why is this dude able to compete against women half his age when he's fucking 50 years old? 

They have their black-and-white all-or-nothing thinking on this as their main thesis. And they think everyone is a narcissist. That's why they attack Riley Gaines for finishing fifth, even though she's a multi-time national champion and her criticism has nothing to do with the fact that Lia Thomas beat her in a single race. It's about the fact that Thomas participating at all takes a spot from women. The fact that any trans woman dominates is worse because it's taking both spots and victories. In college sports this especially matters because those spots and victories are tied to scholarships and opportunities. If Thomas or any other trans woman never gets higher than 4th that's still shunting every single other woman down a single spot which can mean the difference between a scholarship and nothing or a spot on a national team and nothing.

But they laser in on the wins or first place finishes as if that's what matters. They're trying to take advantage of the good faith intrinsic in ignorance to convince people to just DISMISS THE CONCERNS rather than actually look into them. It's the same thing they do with every single issue on this topic whether it's bathrooms, other women's spaces, "medical care", kids, etc. They try to manipulate it so your concerns aren't valid while demanding their concerns take priority over all of society.

Yeah? Well nobody would ever do this because Gender is holy and inviolable. Do you think someone would just like, pretend to be a woman for riches and fame once they've realised that the current plan is going nowhere and they're going to live an entire life without being famous 

That's without mentioning that in the top 100 people of all time only 50 of them are trans