Journal of Other Forum Analysis (Volume II, Issue 2)

[benji]

The problem is not that the extreme views “disqualify” of his decent views, but how the hell he come to this conclusions and why is worth his time to listen all that shit for run of mill “decent” opinions that probably most people have. 

Feels like both dont want to actually discuss why his views were abhorrent and prefer just to silence one and another with gotchas. (Yeah, Benji, I know this also applies to me at times).

Both him and his dad are idiots.

I think it's most likely the dad's point is more that one subset of views should not be how you evaluate a person's views versus their entire body of views. I don't think he literally means to spend your time listening to Charlie Kirk, that was assumed in the complaint from his son about Kirk's views. I figure if the son had said "Charlie Kirk is dumb and he was terrible at what he did" there wouldn't be the challenge from the dad because that's a legitimate reason to not listen to Kirk. I assume the son was lecturing his dad about what Kirk believed while the dad accurately suspected his son was repeating what he'd heard about Kirk and wasn't actually judging him based on any experience with his work.

A similar example would be all the posts denying that Destiny is "left-wing" because he said slurs or supports Israel while ignoring the other 90% of his views.

[Gamegirl Nostalgia]

My father always told me to watch and read from all news outlets and read between the lines because there is bias everywhere. 

[Boredfrom]

The problem is not that the extreme views “disqualify” of his decent views, but how the hell he come to this conclusions and why is worth his time to listen all that shit for run of mill “decent” opinions that probably most people have. 

Feels like both dont want to actually discuss why his views were abhorrent and prefer just to silence one and another with gotchas. (Yeah, Benji, I know this also applies to me at times).

Both him and his dad are idiots.

I think it's most likely the dad's point is more that one subset of views should not be how you evaluate a person's views versus their entire body of views. I don't think he literally means to spend your time listening to Charlie Kirk, that was assumed in the complaint from his son about Kirk's views. I figure if the son had said "Charlie Kirk is dumb and he was terrible at what he did" there wouldn't be the challenge from the dad because that's a legitimate reason to not listen to Kirk. I assume the son was lecturing his dad about what Kirk believed while the dad accurately suspected his son was repeating what he'd heard about Kirk and wasn't actually judging him based on any experience with his work.

A similar example would be all the posts denying that Destiny is "left-wing" because he said slurs or supports Israel while ignoring the other 90% of his views.

But then again… is his dad.

[Uncle]

Just had a conversation with my father that essentially boiled down to "maybe he had some extreme views, but have a you bothered to listen to any of his reasonable ones?". When I essentially said no, he hit me with "not so open minded of you, eh?" Like what do you even say to that? How is it not painfully obvious that the extreme views are the disqualifier for any alleged decent ones? Like we can't go find people with decent views who also, you know, don't simultaneously hold all the terrible ones.

" Dad, are you high?"

Maybe if the left actually had a version of Charlie Kirk who went out and spoke on college campuses instead of sitting on some stream every day eating food and complaining it would help your cause. I didn't agree with Kirk but he actually put in the ground work. The online lefts issue is that they're so insulated that they are unwilling to speak with the other side. Creating some sort of common ground to pull aside centrists or center-rights who are questioning Trumps actions would be a nice idea compared to, you know, DUNKING on stupid jerk faces on reddit, twitter, or bluesky so you feel heckin validated.

Stop purity testing and actually have conversations. Something to think about. But I understand that a lot of y'all have anxiety and that's a lot of work.   

they didn't because they didn't need to, US college is a fully ideologically captured space, you're just preaching to the choir

imagine putting up a tent, "CHANGE MY MIND: ILLEGAL IMMIGRANT MEXICANS SHOULDN'T BE DEPORTED," what do you think would happen to anyone who actually tried to change their mind?

it only worked because charlie was an outsider and wouldn't be ostracized by his peers at that college, and couldn't be expelled for making other students feel unsafe

[Gamegirl Nostalgia]

It's called having conversations, Uncle. It's what Charlie would have wanted. 

[Gamegirl Nostalgia]

And they can put up a tent across the street from Walmart. Where the red blooded American shops.  

[EaldNarche]

i think the charlie kirk thread is gone on resetera? it just vanished on me after i refreshed it. :v Are they scared of the FBI going through it?

[Gamegirl Nostalgia]

LOL THEY HID THE CHARLIE THREAD

[benji]

But then again… is his dad.

I consider most ResetERA.com posters to be unreliable narrators especially when they're telling stories they're trying to get affirmed on/about. One of the flaws of their deep empathy I suppose.

[HaughtyFrank]

i think the charlie kirk thread is gone on resetera? it just vanished on me after i refreshed it. :v Are they scared of the FBI going through it?

It's members only now. They're probably scared of the Charlie Kirk cancel squad.

[Gamegirl Nostalgia]

but cancel culture doesn't exist..

[benji]

i think the charlie kirk thread is gone on resetera? it just vanished on me after i refreshed it. :v Are they scared of the FBI going through it?

It's members only now. They're probably scared of the Charlie Kirk cancel squad.

But why? One of the two rules is don't be an asshole.

[Gamegirl Nostalgia]

Bet they hid it because of the FBI confirmation of the trans relationship.

[Boredfrom]

Uncle, the college allowed him to speak in the campus. A group of students paid him to go to the Campus.

[Boredfrom]

Bet they hid it because of the FBI confirmation of the trans relationship.

For real?  

They did?

[Gamegirl Nostalgia]

Fox news said so 

only other source I've found is https://www.axios.com/2025/09/13/kirk-suspect-transgender-roommate

[Besticus Maximus]

Hecht has found the room mate's account 

[Potato]

Yeah, this could very well be another Paul Pelosi’s gay lover fanfic. Wait for more information to come out

It's really frustrating that even journalists do this shit. Yesterday a guy from the young Turks claimed that the shooter was a huge Nick Fuentes fan and then never followed it up

The news media environment is total shitshow right now. Everyone is trying to be a goddamn influencer and content creator. 

Even Kirk's own widow was shoving a phone camera up close to the corpse of her husband on twitter for likes three days after he died. Normally families would take some time to privately grieve when a tragedy hits but we're living in some strange times.

If you looked at the viewing history of most Resetera members, you would think they were all alt right bigots who religiously watch every single conservative streamer on the internet.

If you dug a little into their background you'd also find that they come from a conservative religious family in some backwater shithole US state and were heavily Republican as a school kid and only recently discovered communism. 

You'd also find plenty of photos of them posing with their newly acquired guns and their social media would show a detailed history of the people they think should be shotgunned to death in the streets. 

[Boredfrom]

So still dunno for sure, right?

[Potato]

The more I read this shit the more it pisses me off

well said.
the most vulnerable members of society should not have this insane burden on their shoulders.

What's the evidence that trans people are the most vulnerable members of society?

How many self diagnosed illnesses do you need them to list, chud?

[benji]

Uncle, the college allowed him to speak in the campus. 

They're legally required to.

That's why conservative speakers usually have to be disrupted in other ways:

Spoiler: a few examples of something very common (click to show)(click to hide)

https://news.berkeley.edu/2017/02/01/yiannopoulos-event-canceled/




The Blackman one is my favorite because he's a nobody hack from a fraud college who's endlessly wrong about the law and they're acting like he's this great evil.

[Gamegirl Nostalgia]

So still dunno for sure, right?

I edited the post to add https://www.axios.com/2025/09/13/kirk-suspect-transgender-roommate

but that's the only other source right now. 

[saltygeneraltso]

Did that mod that works for the police and denied Oct 7 rapes ever post their thoughts in that thread? Just jaqqing off for a friend.

[Potato]

Imagine if tiktok was around during any other high-profile political assassination in US history. Imagine this guy being on the Grassy Knoll with a phone camera trying to loot JFK's grey matter from the pavement right after it happened
 

The fact that it's a repost of a repost on an entirely different platform is the most 2025 thing about it.

[DavidCroquet]

Bet they hid it because of the FBI confirmation of the trans relationship.

i won’t make an account just for this. i won’t!

[Boredfrom]

Uncle, the college allowed him to speak in the campus. 

They're legally required to.

That's why conservative speakers usually have to be disrupted in other ways:



https://news.berkeley.edu/2017/02/01/yiannopoulos-event-canceled/

I really hate that weak ass shit.

[cRumB]

NGL I had no idea who this Kirk guy was till he got shot, rip I guess?

[nachobro]

Looks like the killer had a "transgender lover." Is this the end of the "he was so right wing that he killed Charlie Kirk for being to his left" narrative?

wow dudes rock

[Alpacx]

Wait, this is the evidence he "dressed as Pepe"?


That's just a gropnik.

Dude's too lazy to paint his skin. Say what you can about Justin Trudeau but at least he was a leftist dedicated to his consumes.

[Potato]

Wait, this is the evidence he "dressed as Pepe"?


That's just a gropnik.

he's a product of the internet meme culture.. what kid wasn't dressing as some stupid meme back then? Do they easily forget how absolute REDDIT some people were?

Top page Kpop demon hunter

You know what I haven't seen a lot of? K-pop Demon Hunters cosplay. 

That's a topic that's ripe for some cancellations. 

Is it cultural appropriation for some big tiddy cosplay whore to dress up as an animated Korean pop star?